Why Clocks Run Slow: Time Dilation Without the Math

Richard Feynman Clarifying physics
TimeDilation SpecialRelativity LightClock SpeedOfLight Geometry
Outline

Why Clocks Run Slow: Time Dilation Without the Math

Why Light’s Speed Forces Time to Flex

Here’s the foundational fact of relativity: the speed of light is the same in every reference frame. You can’t make light go faster by chasing it. You can’t make it go slower by running away. Measure it from Earth, measure it from a rocket ship, measure it from anything—you always get the same number: 299,792,458 meters per second.

This sounds like a simple speed limit. But it forces something profound: time itself must be flexible.

Think about it. If I’m moving toward a light beam and you’re standing still, we both measure the light passing us at the same speed. That shouldn’t work. If I’m moving, shouldn’t I measure the light going slower relative to me? Nope. We both get the same answer.

The only way that’s possible is if our clocks—our measurements of time itself—are running at different rates. If light’s speed is absolute, time must adjust. Time dilation isn’t some weird side effect of relativity. It’s forced by the constancy of c.

Let me show you why.

The Clock Made of Mirrors

Picture the simplest possible clock: two parallel mirrors with a photon bouncing between them. Light leaves the bottom mirror, travels up to the top mirror, bounces back down. Each round trip is one tick.

The distance between mirrors is L. Light travels at speed c. So the time for one tick—photon goes up, photon comes back—is just distance divided by speed: t = 2L/c.

This is a real clock. It measures time intervals. If you want, you can calibrate it to seconds by choosing L appropriately. One nanosecond per tick? Set L to about 15 centimeters. The physics doesn’t care.

Now here’s the key: this is the time measured in the clock’s own reference frame. The clock is sitting still relative to itself. The photon goes straight up and straight down. Call this the “proper time”—the time experienced by the clock itself.

Now take that clock and move it sideways at velocity v. What happens?

Taking the Diagonal Path

In the moving clock’s frame, nothing changes. The photon still goes straight up and down between the mirrors. Still takes time t = 2L/c. The clock doesn’t know it’s moving—there’s no preferred reference frame.

But from your frame, watching the clock zoom past, something different is happening. While the photon travels upward, the mirrors move sideways. The photon doesn’t travel straight up anymore. It travels diagonally.

Draw it out. The photon starts at the bottom mirror. By the time it reaches the top mirror, that mirror has moved to the side by distance vΔt, where Δt is the time (in your frame) for the photon to make the trip. The photon’s path forms the hypotenuse of a right triangle.

One leg of the triangle is L (vertical distance between mirrors). The other leg is vΔt (horizontal distance the mirror moved). The hypotenuse—the path the photon actually travels—has length √(L² + (vΔt)²).

But the photon still travels at speed c. That’s the whole point. So the distance it travels divided by c gives you the time in your frame:

c·Δt = √(L² + (vΔt)²)

Square both sides:

c²Δt² = L² + v²Δt²

Rearrange:

Δt² (c² - v²) = L²

Δt = L / √(c² - v²)

Factor out c from the denominator:

Δt = L / (c√(1 - v²/c²))

Remember that L/c is half of t, the proper time for half a tick. So for a full tick:

Δt = t / √(1 - v²/c²)

That square root term is called gamma, γ. It’s the time dilation factor. For the moving clock, one tick takes longer. The moving clock runs slow.

This is pure geometry. The photon has to travel a longer path. Light speed is constant. Longer path at same speed means more time. That’s it.

Not Just Light—Everything Slows Down

You might think: okay, fine, light clocks run slow when they move. But what about other kinds of clocks? Mechanical clocks, atomic clocks, biological aging?

Here’s the profound thing: ALL clocks slow down by the same factor. Time itself dilates.

If only light clocks slowed down, you could detect absolute motion. Put a light clock next to a mechanical clock. If they ticked at different rates when moving, you’d know you were moving. But relativity says there’s no preferred frame. No experiment can detect absolute motion.

Therefore, if light clocks slow down by factor γ, everything must slow down by factor γ. Atomic vibrations, chemical reactions, radioactive decay, neural firing—every physical process that could function as a clock must keep pace. Otherwise you’d have a way to detect absolute motion.

This isn’t a hypothesis. It’s a consequence of the relativity principle plus the light clock argument.

And experiments confirm it. Muons created in the upper atmosphere by cosmic rays should decay before reaching the ground—their half-life is only 2.2 microseconds. But they’re moving at 99.9% of light speed. Time dilation stretches that half-life by a factor of about 22. We detect muons at sea level because their clocks are running slow.

GPS satellites experience both effects: velocity time dilation from their orbital speed (slowing their clocks) and gravitational time dilation from being further from Earth’s gravitational well (speeding their clocks). Without correcting for both, GPS positioning would drift by kilometers per day.

This is not theoretical. It’s engineering.

When Geometry Dictates Time

Time dilation isn’t mysterious. It’s a geometric necessity forced by one fact: light travels at the same speed in all frames.

The moving photon takes a diagonal path. The diagonal is longer than the vertical. Same speed, longer path, more time. The ratio of times is exactly the Lorentz factor γ = 1/√(1 - v²/c²).

You’re always moving through spacetime at speed c—the “four-velocity.” But that motion distributes between space and time. Stand still in space? All your motion goes through time. Move through space? Some of your motion diverts from the time dimension. The faster you move spatially, the slower you move temporally.

This is what people mean when they say “time is the fourth dimension.” It’s not metaphor. Spatial motion and temporal flow trade off against each other, governed by the spacetime metric. Time dilation is the geometric shadow of that trade-off.

At everyday speeds—cars, airplanes, even rockets—v²/c² is so tiny that γ is almost exactly 1. Time dilation exists but it’s unmeasurable without atomic clocks. At 99% light speed, γ is about 7. At 99.9%, it’s about 22. As v approaches c, gamma approaches infinity. You’d need infinite energy to reach light speed—it’s an asymptotic limit.

The beauty is how one simple principle—c is invariant—forces time to be flexible. Einstein didn’t invent time dilation because it sounded cool. He discovered it because consistency demanded it. If light’s speed is absolute, and if there’s no preferred reference frame, then moving clocks must run slow.

The light clock shows you why. No equations hiding the mechanism. Just a photon, two mirrors, and geometry.

That’s relativity.

Source Notes

6 notes from 1 channel