How to Science [Part 3: Experiments]

Welch Labs
Dec 10, 2017
8 notes
8 Notes in this Video

Mersenne's Method: Pendulum-Based Frequency Measurement

FrequencyMeasurement PendulumClock CountingMethod ExperimentalTechnique
00:17

Marin Mersenne used pendulums as timekeeping references to measure string vibration frequencies by having one person count string vibrations while another counts pendulum swings.

Scale Models: Slowing Vibrations by Increasing String Length

ScaleModels ExperimentalDesign SlowMotion PhysicalScaling
01:56

Mersenne solved the counting problem by building scale models—creating longer and longer vibrating strings until vibrations slowed enough to count directly, sometimes exceeding 100 feet.

High-Speed Cameras: Modern Equivalent to Mersenne's Scaling

HighSpeedPhotography ModernInstrumentation TimeSlowing TechnologicalAnalogy
02:50

Modern experimenters can use high-speed cameras to slow down string vibrations for counting, achieving the same effect as Mersenne’s physical scaling through temporal rather than spatial transformation.

Feynman's Scientific Method: Guess, Compute, Compare

ScientificMethod FeynmanApproach HypothesisTesting TheoryFormation
03:38

Richard Feynman articulated the scientific process for discovering new laws: “First we guess it. Then we compute the consequences of the guess to see what it would imply. Then we compare those computation results to nature, to experiment, to see if it works.”

Educated Guessing: Making Observations Before Hypothesizing

EducatedGuesses ObservationalData PatternRecognition InductiveReasoning
04:41

To make educated guesses about the length-frequency relationship, the video demonstrates collecting observations first—measuring frequencies at different string lengths before proposing mathematical relationships.

Length-Frequency Observations: Inverse Relationship Evidence

InverseRelationship FrequencyData ExperimentalObservations QuantitativePatterns
05:02

Experimental observations reveal that string frequency and length have an inverse relationship: at 40cm the string vibrates at 122 Hz, at 80cm (double length) it vibrates at 65 Hz, and at 20cm (half length) it vibrates at 245 Hz.

Specific Predictions: Testable Quantitative Forecasts Required

SpecificPredictions QuantitativeTesting FalsifiableHypotheses ExactForecasts
06:00

Feynman’s method requires guesses to be “specific enough to produce exact predictions”—vague qualitative statements don’t constitute testable hypotheses.

Experimental Test Setup: Designing Validation Trials

ExperimentalDesign ValidationTests ControlledVariation IndependentTesting
06:08

The video establishes an experimental test: using a string at 3,200g tension and 40cm length (174 Hz baseline), predict frequencies at 80cm, 50cm, and 20cm to validate the length-frequency hypothesis.